The relationship of cause to effect is not the same thing as the relationship between cost and benefit, or what I would describe as a transactional relationship—one in which I do something for you and then you do something for me. When it comes to our relationship to God, it’s definitely not a transactional one, however much we have tried to describe it with the language of contract law, or covenant. Jesus was clear about that early and often in his ministry, and that’s one reason why we so often hear him talking in language that upends our expectations using statements such as “For those who want to save their life will lose it, and those who lose their life for my sake, and for the sake of the gospel, will save it,” or “The last shall be first and the first shall be last.” He might be talking about biological life and death, with these sentiments, but that was HIS journey, and don’t assume yours is like it. Jesus might as well have screamed, “Let go you silly people! It’s not what you think! Let go of who you think God is, because however much you believe your hearts and minds can contain the depth and breadth of God’s love, they cannot.”
The Lenten journey of self-discovery is meant to loosen our death grip on our expectations of how we should relate to God and our neighbors. It is meant to help us learn to be in relationship with God and with our neighbor purely for the experience of joy and wisdom without defining a reward that we presume to be commensurate with our goodness. When we recognize that we can relate to God as we relate to our vitality—to the breath of life, we can then engage in a cause and effect relationship. HOWEVER… that is because God is consistently pure and steadfast love, freely offered, whether or not we do this or that thing. We cannot earn God’s love and that is why we say we are “saved from sin” by grace alone; not by works, however good they may be. And because sin is simply whatever it is that separates us from God, the meaning of being saved from sin is the explanation that it is the nature of God that keeps us from ever truly being separated. After all, we live in God—the whole universe lives in God. As St. Paul is quoted to have said to the Athenians in the Acts of the Apostles, this is the same God “in whom we live and move and have our being.” When we enter into the experience of deep relationship with God, we simply must refrain from assuming we know what our lives should look like and what our rewards should be. It’s not “fee for service.” That’s why we had the reformation 500 years ago. Neither the sacraments nor God’s love are for sale. They’re freely given—no strings.
It’s hard to even choose words to talk about these things because our very language is so replete with words that make so much of human interaction sound like a commercial transaction. But if we look deeply at the words Jesus said to his disciples and the crowds: “If any want to become my followers, let them deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me. For those who want to save their life will lose it, and those who lose their life for my sake, and for the sake of the gospel, will save it.” Even though he did prophecy his coming suffering and murder to the disciples, he’s not telling the assembled crowd that they will be tortured and killed. What he is saying is that one must deny self-centered focus. They might have to buck the civil authorities—he’s using the language of the cross, because it was common for the Romans to crucify political opposition or whomever they perceived as a threat to the social order, forcing the convicted to carry the horizontal cross beam from which they hung on the cross. Jesus is telling the crowd, “don’t be obsessed with a problem as small as the fulfillment of worldly needs when instead you can be thinking in the context of eternity.” He points out the folly of transactional living when he asks, “What can they give in return for their life?” There is nothing we can offer God that is commensurate with the value of life in Christ Jesus, so don’t even try to think that way. Accepting the grace means turning away from petty self-interest and turning toward God. When we turn toward God, the Body of Christ is reflected back. Not just our own image. We can’t even see it if we are holding on to our ideas, which hang like a cloud of dense fog between us and God, obscuring that beautiful glimpse of divine glory.